Sugar and Spice Order

Online Ordering

Online ordering is temporarily unavailable.

Please call 812-855-8810 to place your order.

You may also reach us by email at



Cake orders will not be finalized until your order is confirmed by one of our bakery staff. If you have any questions, please call 812-855-8810.

For customized wedding cakes please contact us at 812-855-8810.

Gift Packages

Sugar and Spice Popcorn Specialty Gift Box

Choose your favorite popcorn flavors.

Five bags $29.99

Three bags $17.99

Care Packages

All oversized orders—either by size or by weight—must be quoted by our sales representative.


Shipping and Processing

Note: We only ship cookies.

All delivery days refer to business days—Monday through Friday, excluding holidays.

Standard shipping charges cover the costs incurred to prepare, process, and transport your order. Standard rates are based on UPS Ground Delivery within the continental United States. Other delivery methods are available but must be quoted for each order. We ship to most areas outside of the continental United States. Shipping charges vary by destination. When placing your order, please ask about shipping charges. We are unable to ship to P.O. boxes and APO addresses via UPS. 

UPS will deliver approximately between 8 a.m. until 8 p.m. (extended times may apply during the holidays). If you must have your gift delivered on a specific date, we suggest the use of overnight delivery to guarantee the delivery date.

Please check your address information carefully. We cannot extend our guarantee to orders with incorrect addresses. Areas impacted by extreme weather conditions may result in a delay in delivery. We thank you in advance for your understanding during these rare instances.

Any package unable for delivery due to incorrect information, untimely picked up by the recipient or when the recipient is no longer at the given address, which is then returned to Sugar and Spice, will not be refunded and will only be reshipped at the customer's cost and request.

Regarding untimely pickups: UPS will deliver the package at the delivery address without a signature unless the driver determines that the location is not sufficiently secure. If this happens, UPS will attempt to make a delivery up to three times. On the third attempt, a notice will be left for the recipient to pick up the package at a designated UPS depot. If delivery does not happen after these attempts are made, the perishable package will be sent back to Sugar and Spice.

Due to the abundance of holiday orders between November 15 and December 24: Orders must be placed at least five business days in advance to assure on-time delivery. During this period, orders over 10 items must be placed at a minimum of seven business days beforehand.